Policy Number: 1-004
Substantive Change
Category: Academic Affairs
Responsible Executive: Provost and Senior Vice President of Academic Affairs
1.PURPOSE
Accredited institutions with the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Commission on Colleges (SACSCOC) are required to notify SACSCOC of substantive changes, and when required, obtain approval before initiating such changes. Failing to comply with the SACSCOC Substantive Change Policy and Procedures may cause an institution to lose its accreditation. As a result, the institution may lose its Title IV funding or be required to reimburse the U.S. Department of Education for money received by the institution for programs related to the unreported substantive change.
2.APPLICABILITY
Faculty, Staff, University Direct Support Organizations, and University Affiliate Entities.
3.DEFINITIONS
3.1 Branch campus means an off-campus instructional site or additional location that:
- is geographically apart from main campus;
- is a location where instruction is delivered; and
- is independent of main campus.
3.2 Off-campus instructional site means a campus independent of the main campus that:
- is permanent;
- offers courses in educational programs leading to a degree, diploma, certificate, or other for-credit credential;
- has its own faculty and administrative or supervisory organization; and
- has its own budgetary and hiring authority.
3.3 Closure means the ending of instruction such that a student cannot complete their program of study as planned in the following circumstances:
- in an educational program;
- at off-campus instructional site;
- in an educational program at an off-campus instructional site or main campus;
- by a method of delivery; or
- at an entire institution.
3.4 Competency-based education means a method of delivery in which competencies are learned through interaction with faculty and an academic credential is earned based on what students demonstrate they can do. A competency is a well-defined statement of what a person can do because of learning. Progression and completion are measured by demonstrated attainment of competencies.
3.4.1 Competency-based education by course or credit-based approach:
Demonstrating competencies is embedded in a traditional curriculum with courses completed, credits earned, and a credential awarded. Students typically enroll in an academic term and course credits are awarded at the end of the term by demonstrating mastery of the competencies associated with a course. Students may accelerate learning through demonstration of competencies. Transcripts record courses and grades, though the institution may opt to maintain a separate transcript of competencies.
3.4.2 Competency-based education by direct assessment:
Progression and completion of a program is based solely on demonstrating mastery of prescribed competencies. There are no academic terms (e.g., calendars), courses, or credit hours. Students progress through a program’s competencies at their own pace within limits, if any, established by the institution. The academic transcript consists of successfully demonstrated competencies and the level of mastery attained.
3.5 Cooperative academic arrangement means an agreement between a SACSCOC-accredited institution and another entity (or entities) to deliver program content recorded on the SACSCOC institution’s transcript as its own. Examples include geographic or denominational consortia, statewide distance education agreements, collaborative agreements with international institutions, and contractual instruction.
3.6 Correspondence courses means courses in which students and instructors are not in the same locations and in which instructional materials and learning assessments (such as examinations, assignments, creative works, etc.) are delivered electronically or by mail. Interaction between instructor and the student is limited, is not regular and substantive, and is primarily initiated by the student. Courses are typically self-paced within limits.
3.7 Distance education means a method of delivery in which most instruction occurs when students and instructors are not in the same location. It includes synchronous (live or in real-time) and asynchronous (not live or in real-time) instruction.
3.8 Dual academic award means a student receives instruction at two (or more) institutions in prescribed curricula leading to each institution granting academic awards at the same credential level.
3.9 Educational program means a coherent course of study leading to a for-credit credential including a degree, diploma, certificate, or other generally recognized credential. Exception: General education, for substantive change purposes, is usually considered a program even if a credential is not awarded.
3.10 Joint academic award means a student receives instruction at two (or more) institutions in prescribed curricula leading to the institutions granting a single academic award bearing the names, seals, and officials’ signatures of each participating institution.
3.11 Method of delivery means the principal method by which instruction is delivered to include:
- competency-based education (all forms):
- distance education; and
- face-to-face instruction.
3.12 Notification means an official communication from an institution to SACSCOC summarizing the institution’s proposed change. A notification is complete only when accepted by SACSCOC upon satisfactory review by staff.
3.13 Off-campus instructional site or additional location means a location geographically apart from an institution’s sole main campus and where instruction is delivered. An off-campus instructional site may qualify as a branch campus.
3.14 Teach-out agreement means an optional written agreement with an institution or entity under which students covered by a teach-out plan may complete their programs of study. A teach-out agreement may include student eligibility criteria, time limits, fee waivers, tuition parity, or other negotiated terms.
3.15 Teach-out plan means a written plan developed by an institution for students to complete their programs of study because it decided to end a program, off-campus instructional site, method of delivery, or to close the institution. A teach-out plan provides an orderly process, the equitable treatment of students, minimal disruption and additional costs to students, and covers all enrolled students regardless of their progress to completion.
4.POLICY STATEMENT
Accredited institutions with the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Commission on Colleges (SACSCOC) are required to notify SACSCOC of substantive changes, and when required, obtain approval before initiating such changes. Failing to comply with the SACSCOC Substantive Change Policy and Procedures may cause an institution to lose its accreditation. As a result, the institution may lose its Title IV funding or be required to reimburse the U.S. Department of Education for money received by the institution for programs related to the unreported substantive change.
4.1 Changes Requiring Reporting
The University must comply with the SACSCOC Substantive Change Policy by reporting substantive changes to SACSCOC concerning the following:
- Changing substantially the established mission or objectives of an institution or its programs;
- Changing the legal status, form of control, or ownership of an institution;
- Changing the governance of an institution;
- Merging or consolidating two or more institutions or entities;
- Acquiring another institution or any program or location of another institution;
- Relocating an institution or an off-campus instructional site of an institution (including a branch campus);
- Offering courses or programs at a higher or lower degree level than currently authorized;
- Adding graduate programs at an institution previously offering only undergraduate programs (including degrees, diplomas, certificates, and other for-credit credentials);
- Changing the way an institution measures student progress, whether in clock hours or credit-hours; semesters, trimesters, or quarters; or time-based or non-time-based methods or measures;
- Adding a program that is a significant departure from the existing programs, or method of delivery, from those offered when the institution was last evaluated;
- Initiating programs by distance education or correspondence courses;
- Adding an additional method of delivery to currently offered programs;
- Entering into a cooperative academic arrangement;
- Entering into a written arrangement under 34 C.F.R. § 668.5 under which an institution or organization not certified to participate in title IV Higher Education Act (HEA) programs offers less than 25% (notification) or 25-50% (approval) of one or more of the accredited institution’s educational programs. An agreement offering more than 50% of one or more of an institution’s programs is prohibited by federal regulation;
- Increasing or decreasing substantially the number of clock hours or credit hours award or competencies demonstrated, or an increase in the level of credential awarded, for successful completion of one or more programs;
- Adding competency-based education programs;
- Adding each competency-based education program by direct assessment;
- Adding programs with completion pathways that recognize and accommodated a student’s prior or existing knowledge or competency;
- Awarding dual or joint academic awards;
- Reopening a previously closed program or off-campus instructional site;
- Adding a new off-campus institutional site or additional location including a branch campus;
- Adding a permanent location at a site at which an institution is conducting a teach-out program for students of another institution that has ceased operating before all students have completed their program of study; or
- Closing an institution, a program, a method of delivery, an off-campus instructional site, or a program at an off-campus instructional site.
- Responsibility
4.2.1 Responsibilities of Assistant and Associate Provosts, Vice Presidents, Deans, and Directors
Assistant and associate provosts, vice presidents, deans, and directors have the fundamental responsibility to be generally aware of the Substantive Change Policy, inform the appropriate associate provost at the earliest point possible of proposals that may be considered a substantive change for the University, and provide any data, information, or prospectus necessary to comply with SACSCOC Substantive Change Policy when requested.
4.2.2 Responsibilities of Associate Provost and Director and Associate Provost for Teaching and Technology
All substantive changes will be coordinated through either an associate provost and SACSCOC Liaison or the Associate Provost for Teaching and Technology. After an associate provost is notified of the substantive change, if not the SACSCOC liaison, that associate provost will then notify the University’s SACSCOC Liaison of the change(s) for communicating the change(s) with SACSCOC.
4.2.3 Responsibilities of the University’s SACSCOC Liaison
The University’s SACSCOC liaison will:
- Provide the appropriate associate provost with information about the SACSCOC substantive change policy. This includes, but is not limited to, maintaining a section on UF’s SACSCOC website concerning substantive change and sending information about substantive change to the Assistant and Associate Provosts, Vice Presidents, Deans, and Directors at least annually;
- Coordinate with appropriate personnel to determine whether a proposed change is substantive;
- Oversee the process of meeting SACSCOC submission deadlines and appropriate reporting or requesting approval of institutional substantive changes;
- Coordinate with SACSCOC and the appropriate associate provost about any required follow-up action; and
- Make recommendations to the Provost for updating this policy as SACSCOC policies and principles change.
The current university SACSCOC Liaison is:
Dr. Cheryl Gater
Associate Provost and SACSCOC Institutional Liaison
(352) 392-4208
cgater@aa.ufl.edu
4.3 Reporting Procedures
Appendix A is a complete listing of substantive changes, timeline for notification or approval, and documentation requirements for reporting the change to SACSCOC.
4.3.1 Notification of the University’s SACSCOC Liaison of Proposed Changes
Notification must be made to the University’s SACSCOC Liaison at the earliest stage of consideration for any proposed change that could be deemed substantive according to the latest SACSCOC Substantive Change Policy.
Substantive changes must be implemented in accordance with the SACSCOC timeline and only after the SACSCOC Liaison has confirmed that the University has developed and submitted the required information to SACSCOC.
4.3.2 Late Notification to University’s SACSCOC Liaison
If a substantive change has been implemented without notification to the University’s SACSCOC Liaison, the appropriate associate provost must notify the University’s SACSCOC Liaison immediately. The University’s SACSCOC Liaison must then notify the SACSCOC of the change as provided in the SACSCOC Substantive Change Policy and Procedures .
To ensure that proposals that may be considered substantive changes do not go unreported, assistant and associate provosts, vice presidents, deans, and directors should review internal processes to confirm timely reporting of substantive changes.
Appendix A
Program Changes | |||||
Type of Sub Change |
Action Required by SACSCOC |
By Whom in SACSCOC |
Timeframe for Submission to SACSCOC Prior to Planned Implementation |
Documentation Required by SACSCOC |
Timeframe for Notifying the University SACSCOC Liaison Prior to Implementation |
Cooperative Academic Agreement with Title IV Entities (if 50% or more of a program is offered through the arrangement OR the SACSCOC institution could not deliver the program without the arrangement, i.e., it is dependent on the arrangement to deliver a program) | Notification | Any time before implementation | Notification and associated SACSCOC-required documents | At least 3 months prior to implementation | |
Cooperative Academic Agreement with Non-Title IV Entities – Between 25-50% of a program’s content recorded on UF transcript | Approval | Executive Council | January 1 for changes to be implemented July 1 through December 31 of the same calendar yearJuly 1 for changes to be implemented January 1 through June 30 of the subsequent calendar year | Prospectus | At least 10 months prior to implementation |
Cooperative Academic Agreement with Non-Title IV Entities – Less than 25% of a program’s content recorded on UF transcript | Notification | Any time before implementation | Notification and SACSCOC-required documentation | At least 3 months prior to implementation | |
Dual Academic Award – An arrangement in which a student receives instruction at two (or more) institutions in prescribed curricula leading to each institution granting academic awards at the same credential level. | Notification | Any time before implementation | Notification and SACSCOC-required documentation | At least 3 months prior to implementation | |
Joint Academic Award with non-SACSCOC Institution(s). A student receives instruction at two (or more) institutions, where at least one is a non-SACSCOC institution or entity, in prescribed curricula leading to the institutions granting a single academic award bearing the names, seals, and officials’ signatures of each participating institution. | Approval | Executive Council | January 1 for changes to be implemented July 1 through December 31 of the same calendar yearJuly 1 for changes to be implemented January 1 through June 30 of the subsequent calendar year | Prospectus | At least 10 months prior to implementation |
Joint Academic Award with SACSCOC Institution(s). A joint academic award is one in which a student receives instruction at two or more institutions in a prescribed curriculum leading to the institutions granting a single academic award bearing the names, seals, and officials’ signatures of each participating institution. | Notification | Any time before implementation | Notification and SACSCOC-required documentation | At least 3 months prior to implementation | |
Adding a method of delivery to an existing program (applies when 50% or more is delivered by that method) | Approval, if on Restriction; Notification, if not on restriction | If Notification Only, any time before implementation.January 1 for changes to be implemented July 1 through December 31 of the same calendar year
July 1 for changes to be implemented January 1 through June 30 of the subsequent calendar year |
Notification and SACSCOC-required documentation | At least a month prior to implementation | |
Adding a new program with 50-100% new content (including certificates) | Approval | Executive Council | January 1 for changes to be implemented July 1 through December 31 of the same calendar yearJuly 1 for changes to be implemented January 1 through June 30 of the subsequent calendar year | Prospectus | At least 10 months prior to implementation |
Adding a new program with 25-49% new content (including certificates) | Notification | Any time before implementation | Notification and SACSCOC-required documentation | At least a month prior to implementation | |
Program closure (including certificates). Closure is defined as closed to admission or entry, not the cessation of instruction; i.e., closure date is when students can no longer start, not the date instruction ends. | Approval | Executive Council | January 1 for changes to be implemented July 1 through December 31 of the same calendar yearJuly 1 for changes to be implemented January 1 through June 30 of the subsequent calendar year | Teach-out Plan | At least 10 months prior to implementation |
Program Designed for Prior Learning. Initiating a program requiring students to possess prior learning as a condition of admission requires notification prior to implementation. | Notification | Any time before implementation. | Notification and SACSCOC-required documentation | At least a month prior to implementation | |
Program Length Change. A change in program length in which credit hours increase or decrease by 25% or more AND students’ expected time to completion increases or decreases by more than one term (including certificates) | Approval | Executive Committee | January 1 for changes to be implemented July 1 through December 31 of the same calendar yearJuly 1 for changes to be implemented January 1 through June 30 of the subsequent calendar year | Prospectus | At least 10 months prior to implementation |
Program reopening within five years of closure | Notification | Any time before implementation | Notification and SACSCOC-required documentation | At least a month prior to implementation | |
Off-campus Instructional Site / Additional Location Changes | |||||
Type of Sub Change | Action Required by SACSCOC | By Whom in SACSCOC | Timeframe for Submission to SACSCOC Prior to Planned Implementation | Documentation Required by SACSCOC | Timeframe for Notifying the University SACSCOC Liaison Prior to Implementation |
Adding an off-campus instructional site at which 25-49% of a program’s instruction is delivered | Notification | Any time before implementation. | Notification and SACSCOC-required documentation | At least a month prior to implementation | |
Adding an off-campus instructional site at which 50% or more of a program’s instruction is delivered | Approval by extensive review | SACSCOC Board of Trustees | March 15 for review at the June meetingSeptember 1 for review at the December meeting | Prospectus | At least 6 months prior to implementation |
Relocating an approved off-campus instruction site. Moving instruction to a new location geographically separate from – i.e., noncontiguous to – the current location. | Notification | Any time before implementation. | Notification and SACSCOC-required documentation | At least a month prior to implementation | |
Relocating an approved branch campus | Approval | Executive Council | January 1 for changes to be implemented July 1 through December 31 of the same calendar yearJuly 1 for changes to be implemented January 1 through June 30 of the subsequent calendar year | Prospectus | At least 10 months prior to implementation |
Re-opening an approved off-campus instructional site within five years of the closure date | Notification | Any time before implementation. | Notification and SACSCOC-required documentation | At least a month prior to implementation | |
Institutional Changes | |||||
Type of Sub Change | Action Required by SACSCOC | By Whom in SACSCOC | Timeframe for Submission to SACSCOC Prior to Planned Implementation | Documentation Required by SACSCOC | Timeframe for Notifying the University SACSCOC Liaison Prior to Implementation |
Change in Measure of Student Progress to Completion. This includes changes from or to semester, trimester, or quarter academic calendars; time-based (i.e., calendar-based) or non-time based (i.e., competency-based) measures; and clock hour-based or credit hour-based measures. | Approval | Executive Committee | January 1 for changes to be implemented July 1 through December 31 of the same calendar yearJuly 1 for changes to be implemented January 1 through June 30 of the subsequent calendar year | Prospectus | At least 10 months prior implementation |
Governance Change. A governance change may include significantly altering governing board bylaws, the board’s scope of authority or responsibility, the number of board members, or how board members are selected. | Notification + Approval | SACSCOC Board of Trustees | If Notification Only, any time before implementation.March 15 for review at the June meeting
September 1 for review at the December meeting |
Notification (at least six months prior to the meeting in which the prospectus will be reviewed)Prospectus | At least 10 months prior implementation |
Institution, Program, or Location Acquisition | Notification + Approval | SACSCOC Board of Trustees | If Notification Only, any time before implementation.March 15 for review at the June meeting
September 1 for review at the December meeting |
Description of planned change.Intended implementation date.
Intended BOT Meeting (June or December) and year for which institution will submit prospectus. |
At least 10 months prior implementation |
Institutional Contingency Teach-out Plan. An institutional contingency teach-out plan must be approved if any of the following occur:a. the institution is placed or continued on probation or probation for good cause by SACSCOC,
b. SACSCOC acts to end the institution’s accreditation, c. the institution’s state authorization is revoked, d. the institution is on provisional certification for federal financial aid by U.S. Department of Education (USDE), e. the institution is on reimbursement for federal financial aid by USDE, or f. the institution is the subject of emergency action by USDE. |
Approval | Executive Committee | January 1 for changes to be implemented July 1 through December 31 of the same calendar yearJuly 1 for changes to be implemented January 1 through June 30 of the subsequent calendar year | Teach-out plan | At least 10 months prior implementation |
Merger/Consolidation | Notification + Approval | SACSCOC Board of Trustees | If Notification Only, any time before implementation.March 15 for review at the June meeting
September 1 for review at the December meeting |
Notification (at least six months prior to the meeting in which the prospectus will be reviewed)Prospectus | At least 10 months prior implementation |
Mission Change | Approval | Executive Committee | January 1 for changes to be implemented July 1 through December 31 of the same calendar yearJuly 1 for changes to be implemented January 1 through June 30 of the subsequent calendar year | Prospectus | At least 10 months prior implementation |
Ownership, Means of Control, or Legal Status Change | Notification + Approval | SACSCOC Board of Trustees | If Notification Only, any time before implementation.March 15 for review at the June meeting
September 1 for review at the December meeting |
Notification (at least six months prior to the meeting in which the prospectus will be reviewed)Prospectus | At least 10 months prior implementation |
History
History: New 6-23-2021, updated 10-12-2023 (administrative)